Key Takeaways:
- A packaging refresh updates visual elements like graphics, colors and typography while preserving your existing structure and brand equity.
- A packaging redesign involves more comprehensive changes, such as new materials, structural adjustments or a complete reset of your packaging identity.
- Refresh signals include dated design trends, outdated graphics or minor functional improvements that don’t require reworking the core structure.
- Redesign signals include major brand repositioning, loss of shelf differentiation or packaging that no longer meets functional or sustainability requirements.
Your packaging might need an update. Sales trends, competitive shifts or new channel requirements can all signal that change is overdue. The challenge is figuring out how much change makes sense. Some brands need a visual refresh. Others need a structural redesign. This guide helps you identify which approach fits your situation.
Packaging Refresh vs. Redesign: What’s the Difference?
A packaging refresh targets specific updates while preserving your foundation. It can include:
- Graphics and color updates
- Typography refinements
- Print quality improvements
- Minor structural tweaks
A packaging redesign involves more comprehensive changes, such as:
- Brand strategy repositioning
- Structural overhauls with new package forms, materials or configurations
- Complete resets, reimagining of how the package looks, functions and communicates
Neither approach is inherently better. The right choice depends on your brand’s specific situation. Typically, the trigger for both paths is thinking that packaging “looks outdated.” However, surface-level redesigns driven by trend-chasing frequently fail to deliver results.
When a Packaging Refresh Is the Right Call
A refresh is the lower-risk and faster path when your brand’s foundation is strong, but the expression needs updating. Preserving brand recognition is a strategic advantage, and a refresh allows you to modernize without disrupting the equity you’ve worked hard to build.
Design trends evolve constantly. Color palettes shift, typography preferences change and packaging materials take on new aesthetics. But a dated appearance doesn’t always mean the structure or brand identity is broken. If your core brand signals are still recognizable and strong, updating visual elements is often enough.
Research shows that greater familiarity between new and old packaging is linked to positive consumer outcomes. When your packaging foundation serves your brand identity well but the visual execution feels stale, a refresh can bring you up to date.
You can elevate graphic execution without touching the package structure. Adding new or refining existing artwork, updating imagery, enhancing color accuracy and adjusting typography can all help improve shelf presence and brand perception. If your structure is sound but your graphics feel flat, investing in improved printing capabilities can help you close the gap without having to start from scratch.
Adjusting a panel configuration, improving an opening mechanism, refining a window placement or updating material weight are all targeted changes that fall within the refresh category. These adjustments solve specific functional issues without reworking the entire package. Before assuming a full overhaul is needed, it’s best to consult a branded structural packaging design team to evaluate the scope and identify whether a targeted fix will address your needs.

When a Packaging Redesign Is Necessary
A redesign is appropriate when the problems run deeper than aesthetics, and the packaging’s foundation no longer serves the brand’s current reality. Redesigns generally carry more risk and require more investment, which is why strategic intent matters.
Nine out of 10 redesigns fail to deliver meaningful sales lift, underscoring why redesigns should be intentional and why partnering with an experienced team matters.
If your brand has experienced significant shifts, the packaging must reflect that evolution. Examples include:
- Market repositioning: Moving from regional to national distribution or entering new retail channels like mass market or club stores.
- Target audience shifts: Packaging designed for one demographic rarely resonates when your customer base changes.
- Brand values evolution: Sustainability commitments or quality positioning that your current packaging contradicts.
- Product line expansion: New formats or sizes that your existing structure can’t accommodate.
When the disconnect between your packaging and your brand’s positioning is fundamental, a redesign is necessary.
If the structural form or overall visual identity itself is the problem, a redesign is warranted. Here are signs that a surface refresh may not be enough:
- Your packaging no longer stands out in a crowded category.
- Visual standards in your space have shifted, and your packaging feels generic.
- Shoppers walk past your product without registering it.
NGK faced this challenge. Its corrugated packaging provided protection, but it didn’t deliver the premium look their brand needed to differentiate. The material itself limited its graphic capabilities, making it difficult to stand out on the shelf. A structural redesign shifted them to laminated paperboard with a high-quality print surface. Metallic ink, matte varnish and spot-high gloss coating created the professional appearance that corrugated couldn’t achieve.
A structural redesign is necessary when packaging can’t accommodate a new product format, fails to meet retailer structural requirements or no longer reflects the brand’s sustainability commitments. This is especially relevant for brands entering mass-market or club-store channels or those facing increasing pressure to use recyclable or sustainably sourced materials.
Nature’s Benefits wanted its packaging to reflect the natural qualities of its product and meet growing consumer expectations around sustainability. They moved to a paperboard substrate made from 100% Forest Stewardship Council (FSC)-certified controlled wood sources with a natural kraft surface. The eco-friendly packaging helped attract environmentally conscious consumers and introduced a fresh style to the product category that buyers and retailers responded to positively.
How to Weigh the Risk and Investment
Gather these inputs before you commit to either path:
- Sales performance data: Pull reports from the past months and look for velocity declines, lost distribution or category share erosion. If those drops coincide with competitors updating their packaging, your packaging may be part of the problem.
- Consumer feedback: Schedule shopper interviews and ask whether your packaging communicates what the product is, whether it stands out and what they think about the brand when they see it. Their answers will tell you whether the problem is surface-level or deeper.
- Competitive analysis: Put your packaging next to your top three competitors and the category leader. Document the differences in the materials, graphics and structural form. Any gaps you see will clarify whether you need to make minor or major changes.
- Retailer requirements: If you’re entering new retail channels, get the specific structural, dimensional and sustainability standards from those retailers up front. Building to those requirements from the start saves time and avoids expensive revisions.
Frequently Asked Questions
Here are answers to questions we hear regularly from brands deciding between a refresh and a redesign.
The right cadence depends on your brand evolution, competitive activity and market shifts. Regular evaluation helps you catch declining differentiation or brand misalignment before they show up in your sales numbers.
Signs include declining shelf performance, consumer confusion at the point of sale or feedback that the packaging no longer reflects the product or brand.
Timelines vary by scope, but our in-house design, prepress, manufacturing and distribution capabilities help accelerate speed to market. Integrated workflows help minimize delays and ensure tighter coordination from concept to shelf.
Partner With Great Northern Packaging for Your Next Update
For over 60 years, Great Northern Packaging has helped brands bring updated packaging to market with speed and precision. Our team of more than 70 designers and engineers handles everything under one roof, from initial concept through final production and shipping. As an International Safe Transit Association (ISTA)® certified facility with Safe Quality Food (SQF), Sustainable Forestry Initiative (SFI), G7 and International Organization for Standardization (ISO) credentials, we back every project with proven expertise.
Fill out our online form to discuss your packaging goals today.



























